To Delegate or Not to Delegate: The Dilemma of Cognitive Sedentarism.

Media Party
Photo: Ramiro Chanes

By Andrea Schiro, second-year journalism student at ETER.

As part of the eleventh edition of the Media Party, entrepreneur and technologist Santiago Bilinkis presented his book “Artificial: la nueva inteligencia y el contorno de lo humano” (Artificial: The New Intelligence and the Outline of the Human), created in collaboration with Mariano Sigman, a prominent Argentine neuroscientist.

This presentation, which took place on Friday, October 6th at the Konex, was moderated by La Nación newspaper journalist Ernesto Martelli, who spoke with the author about three crucial topics related to artificial intelligence: education, authorship, and the concept of “cognitive sedentarism.”

“I am convinced that the greatest change in humanity is coming. Even greater than what the internet was,” the technologist said, adding: “Mariano and I want people to start using ChatGPT, but to do it well, making the most of it. It’s not an ‘8 tips to use ChatGPT well’ book; that is on YouTube. It is about where we stand as people regarding a device that can produce thought.” Topics related to artificial intelligence mutate constantly, but the author maintains that this book will not lose its relevance for two or three years.

Photo: Ramiro Chanes

The topics of conversation

The conversation delved into the impact of artificial intelligence on the transmission of knowledge in the educational field. What should be done with artificial intelligence in classrooms when faced with, for example, the completion of assignments with the help of a virtual assistant?

First, for Santiago, it makes no sense to ban the chat since it “is here to stay” and it will be crucial for the future to handle it well because it can even become a work tool. “If you ban it in school so that kids really learn, when they get out, they won’t know how to do this thing that is important,” he mentioned.

“Cognitive Sedentarism”

Now, what is necessary to know? And how do we ensure that this knowledge is genuine and not false? For the authors, it depends on what skills we are willing to lose. For example, why do we not know how to start a fire with branches? Because there are matches. And a technology can be something as basic as a match.

“The key is that if there is any skill you are not willing to lose, even when a technology can do it for you, make sure you keep doing it,” he stated. Because otherwise, you would suffer from “cognitive sedentarism,” a concept coined by the authors that means excessively delegating tasks to technology that we can do ourselves and that are important for the development of our skills.

“We humans are slow when walking and we can’t go very far because we get tired. If you have a car, you go much faster and go further, but you don’t move your legs. There is something in the middle, which is the bicycle. The bicycle allows you to go faster (not as fast as the car), go further (not as far as the car), but you are still pedaling. I think a large part of the challenge will be how we integrate these tools like a bicycle and not like a car,” Bilinkis expressed.

“The key is to see where artificial intelligence takes us, not only where we want to go, but the path we want to take,” he assured. “That’s why we didn’t use ChatGPT to write the book. Let’s say the program could write a better book than ours. It wouldn’t be ours. So it’s not about making the best book, it’s about making your own.”

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply